Has CP ever used your idea?

[cheese rox]

Have your ideas ever been on CP? If so, post it here! My idea was the blue water wings! And it came!

[TnT]

Nope, they've never used one of my ideas before. ;)

[Boyinhood]

Nope i emailed them yesterday for a sport that penguins can play together they said they will send it in.

[1nvaderzim]

They used my Idea of keeping the lifeguard chair in the Cave after the summer party. :)

[<><:riley4lyfe:><>™]

No they have never used any of my ideas before.

[Makarov]

I noticed your title was different from your poll so I switched them. They are both grammatically correct.

[Tennis Tiger]

No, I don't even send ideas to Club Penguin, and I never have. =P

[weirdo406]

They dont like me very much down in BC... they've never used my ideas, nor use my blog comments, nor do they ever reply to my emails.... im hated at CP

[cheese rox]

I noticed your title was different from your poll so I switched them. They are both grammatically correct.
Thanks Pitty. Really appreciate it. :rolleyes:

They dont like me very much down in BC... they've never used my ideas, nor use my blog comments, nor do they ever reply to my emails.... im hated at CP

Lol

[Abbx]

Actually I believe they have. I mentioned something about night time to them, and 1 week later they mentioned that there was gonna be a solar eclipse for halloween. Im sure many people suggested it before though, but thats just me lol. I remember another idea, but i cant--oh yeah! I was the first one on the forums to mention the funny glasses. Im 100% sure that idea started off of me.

[darren91]

they never used my ideas ever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ArcboundMyr]

Nope. I sent in an idea for a bank and they said they'd consider it, but that was a while ago. So, no. =?

[Biggyp]

Club Penguin has never used any of my ideas.
Not much of a surprise.:rolleyes:

[!~Hi/2 o o 6~!]

A Surfing Game. :P

I could really care less if my ideas get chosen. There is what, a Million registered users? 500,000? They get E-mails everday for ideas.

[ClubPenguin001]

Ummmm... they've Posted a couple comments Of Mine on the "whats New" page But I think They Never used any Of My ideas!


I Wish They've Had:(


oh well


-youppie A.K.A YOUPZ

[Shiny Fuzz]

They dont like me very much down in BC... they've never used my ideas, nor use my blog comments, nor do they ever reply to my emails.... im hated at CP

they don't hate you, no one has ever replied to me either. they're very busy with thousands of other emails coming in every day. just keep sending them in and hope they reply eventually. :D

[Tarheel 4]

Two of my ideas are said,by Nathan of CP,to be being discussed at the momment.So maby I can vote yes sometime :D.

[Donnybrook]

No, CP has adults that have got an education working for them. I am sure they will not use ideas that mostly 13 and 14 year olds come up with. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they based something off one of our ideas.

[ArcboundMyr]

However, 13 to 14 year olds have a - um... broader... imagination for games of this age range since they're within it.

[Abbx]

No, CP has adults that have got an education working for them. I am sure they will not use ideas that mostly 13 and 14 year olds come up with. However, I wouldn't be surprised if they based something off one of our ideas.

Screenhog basically ASKED us for ideas. They aren't thinking up too many items lately, so they want us to help. They review what we've got. If they dont like the idea, they dont use it. If they like it, they use it. Simple as that.

[ProBo]

I gave them the idea of numbers in safe chat, 2 days later, they posted in the blog that numbers would be put in the safe chat! yay!

[Akgo]

I sent in several!! I sent in an idea about a fishing theme, a snowboarding (or sledding!) theme, and some things from different countries and history. I'm sure other people have sent those in too, but oh well! I sent these in a long time ago!!!!! But I probably wasn't the first. The fishing theme is happening right now, we have a snowboard jacket and goggles and helmet, we had a pilgrims hat and a kimono!!!

[Shiny Fuzz]

However, 13 to 14 year olds have a - um... broader... imagination for games of this age range since they're within it.

i agree. they should listen to us because, you know, we ARE the ones playing the game.

[darthvader101]

I sent a idea for a 1960's party were u could get a peace symbol necklace and ppl could have good protest like "stop the abc to be with me protest" and it would be like the 60's

[Redenator]

Club Penguin has never used one of my ideas.

[!Icy Chris!]

Nope, I never send my ideas to them anyways.

I was thinking about sending an idea for a clothing item. Has anyone heard of the shoe crocs? I see a lot of people wearing them in the summer so I think they should make those.

[Mikepain911]

Nope, I never send my ideas to them anyways.

I was thinking about sending an idea for a clothing item. Has anyone heard of the shoe crocs? I see a lot of people wearing them in the summer so I think they should make those.

I think those would look weird on penguins..................

[esl1000]

Well, I sent in my "friend pop" and here it is.
I LOVE TOAST I LOVE TOAST I LOVE TOASTI was thinking of this. You know how your friends go in the server you are in, but you dont know theyre there? How about this!

Friend Pop-

What if there was a little "Pop!" when a friend comes in the server?
http://img165.imageshack.us/img165/4586/somekindopicie6.jpg
Then itll say, "your friends name here" has logged in.


I would want that. Would you?

Well, that was mine. I tried sending it in, but they they didnt put it on, so its no for me.

[Donnybrook]

Screenhog basically ASKED us for ideas. They aren't thinking up too many items lately, so they want us to help. They review what we've got. If they dont like the idea, they dont use it. If they like it, they use it. Simple as that.

I agree with you there, I am just saying, probably about 99% of there recommendations are 7 year olds asking for the beta hat to come back.

[Playa4ever]

Nope. CP has never used my ideas before. I've sent in about 3 emails with some good suggetions, but they've never used my ideas before. I hope they consider bringing out a golden cape! Now that would be cool!

[Chainzz]

No. I don't know why. Maybe they stink, maybe they didn't see them, or maybe they been posted before. But, a suggestion is a suggestion ;)

[mario-dx]

Actually yes, they used my idea for the book room contest.

[Bad Boy]

It was really close.

So there's this naming competition, on naming the puffles. Since everyone's calling them "Fluff" and "Fluffy" and everything else. So they let us send e-mails with a list of names. I send a few and one of them was "Puffy" or "Puffie". But then they selected the name "Puffle".

Other than that, nope. Hopefully in the future.

[Timjones]

I requested for a Hawaiian Shirt, but it was probably going to be added anyway.

[DrLong]

Well Nope..I wish they used mine. I once suggested for a non-member day which in it a non-member can buy member clothes only. :)

[zmactarheel]

I actually just sent in an idea about a "Block Mail Button", which would stop any mail from being sent to the person with their mail off, and not cause the heart-break of someone saying no. Unfortunately they have not replied back yet.

[Merry Joe]

I actually just sent in an idea about a "Block Mail Button", which would stop any mail from being sent to the person with their mail off, and not cause the heart-break of someone saying no. Unfortunately they have not replied back yet.
I like your idea Tar! No CP never used any of my ideas.-_-

[Munchkin Jay]

Answer to that is yes , they used my idea of a cart pin and the idea of the Message In a Bottle.

[MarioFan107]

Nope I think I only sent one idea in anyway, I think it was a request for a White Penguin Color. xD

MarioFan107-

[Slam Shady]

Never, any of mine...I never had any good ones anyway.

[rouge135]

Yea, They have used a-lot of my ideas.
Mostly Clothing, like the Elf suit from Christmas.
And the whole instruments would play was my idea.
~Rouge135

[shortkid7t9]

Who ever responded yes, i am 100% sure (and Im not trying to damper on your pride here,) that they didnt see your e-mail, letter, what ever and say that is a great idea lets use it. Probably most of the items were a quincidence and thought of by the CP staff, by getting a lot of the letters or just thinking. For example, the green sunglasses, it isnt a special item and we already had red, black, and i think blue, so green was a missing color and it was during the summer party so they needed a new color so the staff said green. It is not like someguy mailed in the letter and taa-da they took your idea. Technically everyone should be saying no, and not like a bad thing it is very unlikely that an idea be taken.

[waterycool]

CP hasn't used my idea before, though I hope someday my idea would be used.

[S7udjack™]

no theve never used mine, but they have used some other ppls ideas on this forums.

[Oceanside344]

They haven't, but I've only sent one idea to them, and I forget what that was.:P

[Mr Booshkah]

Nope, I don't think they have ever used one of my ideas. Although that could change, because I have sent a ton ideas in the past week, including one about an ice rink update that I just sent a few minutes ago.

[Babidu]

Nope, not a single idea from me was used by club penguin.

[waddles 4ever]

Actually I believe they have. I mentioned something about night time to them, and 1 week later they mentioned that there was gonna be a solar eclipse for halloween. Im sure many people suggested it before though, but thats just me lol. I remember another idea, but i cant--oh yeah! I was the first one on the forums to mention the funny glasses. Im 100% sure that idea started off of me.

i sent in the same idea about the night idea but that was in like 2006

[The Dude 95]

I havn't sent any ideas to ClubPenguin so far.
So they havn't used mine.

[Dannyboy]

Sadly, no, NHI has never used my ideas for CP. I truely don't blame them considering they don't know how old I am and they believe basically any idea from a kid is worthless. Hey, that's life.

[Mr_Cash]

my idea was the spiderman penguin wich i made , but they couldnt use it because of copyright
so they made the superhero themed halloween

[cheese rox]

my idea was the spiderman penguin wich i made , but they couldnt use it because of copyright
so they made the superhero themed halloween
Yeah, I e-mailed them about that. They didn't answer me back. :rolleyes: