Deathly Hallows Question?

[Ponchowinz]

If Harry was the seventh Horcrux, was Nagini a Horcrux? Cause Neville killed her, and if she was there would be 8 Horcruxes:
1. Riddle's Diary
2. Marvolo's Ring
3. Slytherin's Locket
4. Huflepuff's Cup
5. Ravenclaw's "Die-dum" (lol, Crabbe is stupid)
6. Nagini(Was she?)
7. Harry
8. Voldemort's Body



And did you cry at the death of any of the characters? I'm the kind of reader that gets too much involved in the story so when someone dies I feel like I lost someone, so I cried when Dumbledore, Fred and Dobby died, not Tonks nor Lupin, cause JK didn't narrate their deaths, and I was sad for Snape, after I read "The Prince's Tale", Fred's death was the saddest for me, cause he was a cool guy and always had good jokes.

[Madfly]

Fred ruled, but George was cooler. He has no ear.:cool:

Harry wasn't a hrocrux, Nagini was.

[conman1001]

All of those were Horcruxes.

VOldemort's soul was so unstable, when he tried to kill Harry is soul split again.:sick:

So there were actually 7 horcruxes+voldemort.

[BaconMan]

If Harry was the seventh Horcrux, was Nagini a Horcrux? Cause Neville killed her, and if she was there would be 8 Horcruxes:
1. Riddle's Diary
2. Marvolo's Ring
3. Slytherin's Locket
4. Huflepuff's Cup
5. Ravenclaw's "Die-dum" (lol, Crabbe is stupid)
6. Nagini(Was she?)
7. Harry
8. Voldemort's Body



And did you cry at the death of any of the characters? I'm the kind of reader that gets too much involved in the story so when someone dies I feel like I lost someone, so I cried when Dumbledore, Fred and Dobby died, not Tonks nor Lupin, cause JK didn't narrate their deaths, and I was sad for Snape, after I read "The Prince's Tale", Fred's death was the saddest for me, cause he was a cool guy and always had good jokes.

Actually, Voldemort's Body wasn't a Horcrux because a Horcrux is a part of the soul that has been encased in something else. And Dobby was my favorite, he was soooo awesome and I was real sad when he died-_-

[Madfly]

All of those were Horcruxes.

VOldemort's soul was so unstable, when he tried to kill Harry is soul split again.:sick:

So there were actually 7 horcruxes+voldemort.

If Harry was a Horcrux than he would have to die for voldermort to be dead.

[conman1001]

If Harry was a Horcrux than he would have to die for voldermort to be dead.

He did.......................

and the spell sort of like killed the part of VOldemort's soul and then Harry was alive because he still had his soul:O

[Bad Boy]

Tom Riddle's Diary
Created with the death of: Moaning Myrtle
Destroyed by: Harry Potter
Destroyed using: Basilisk fang

Marvolo Gaunt's Ring/Resurrection Stone
Created with the death of: Tom Riddle Senior
Destroyed by: Albus Dumbledore
Destroyed using: Sword of Gryffindor

Salazar Slytherin's Locket
Created with the death of: A muggle tramp
Destroyed by: Ron Weasley
Destroyed using: Sword of Gryffindor

Helga Hufflepuff's Cup
Created with the death of: Hepzibah Smith
Destroyed by: Hermione Granger
Destroyed using: Basilisk fang

Rowena Ravenclaw's Diadem
Created with the death of: An Albanian peasant
Destroyed by: Vincent Crabbe
Destroyed using: Fiendfyre
Notes: Destroyed accidentally

Harry Potter
Created with the death of: Lily Potter
Destroyed by: Lord Voldemort
Destroyed using: Avada Kedavra curse
Notes: Created accidentally, Voldemort's ripped soul magically removed from Harry Potter accidentally

Nagini
Created with the death of: Bertha Jorkins
Destroyed by: Neville Longbottom
Destroyed using: Sword of Gryffindor

Wikipedia (source)

[penguindude515]

If Harry was the seventh Horcrux, was Nagini a Horcrux? Cause Neville killed her, and if she was there would be 8 Horcruxes:
1. Riddle's Diary
2. Marvolo's Ring
3. Slytherin's Locket
4. Huflepuff's Cup
5. Ravenclaw's "Die-dum" (lol, Crabbe is stupid)
6. Nagini(Was she?)
7. Harry
8. Voldemort's Body



And did you cry at the death of any of the characters? I'm the kind of reader that gets too much involved in the story so when someone dies I feel like I lost someone, so I cried when Dumbledore, Fred and Dobby died, not Tonks nor Lupin, cause JK didn't narrate their deaths, and I was sad for Snape, after I read "The Prince's Tale", Fred's death was the saddest for me, cause he was a cool guy and always had good jokes.

Yes, those were the hocruxes. (Except for Voldemort, because you can't make yourself a horcrux :rolleyes:)

No, I didn't cry, but I was sad.

P.S. You forgot about Mad Eye.

[shortkid7t9]

Conman was rite, that is why harry kept saying stuff like "I am Voldemort" ! Great book 10/10

[oddball127]

Fred ruled, but George was cooler. He has no ear.:cool:

Harry wasn't a hrocrux, Nagini was.

harry was also a horcurex, he ment for there to be 6 but when harry survived part of voldemorts soul went to the nearest living object

[Rigsandbill]

If Harry was the seventh Horcrux, was Nagini a Horcrux? Cause Neville killed her, and if she was there would be 8 Horcruxes:
1. Riddle's Diary
2. Marvolo's Ring
3. Slytherin's Locket
4. Huflepuff's Cup
5. Ravenclaw's "Die-dum" (lol, Crabbe is stupid)
6. Nagini(Was she?)
7. Harry
8. Voldemort's Body



And did you cry at the death of any of the characters? I'm the kind of reader that gets too much involved in the story so when someone dies I feel like I lost someone, so I cried when Dumbledore, Fred and Dobby died, not Tonks nor Lupin, cause JK didn't narrate their deaths, and I was sad for Snape, after I read "The Prince's Tale", Fred's death was the saddest for me, cause he was a cool guy and always had good jokes.

The way in the sixth book JK described Dumbledore's death made me get tears in my eyes.

"And just like the phoenix that departed, Dumbledore had left Hogwarts forever. Left the mortal world. Left Harry."

I don't know why, but that line was sad to me for some reason.

[oddball127]

The way in the sixth book JK described Dumbledore's death made me get tears in my eyes.

"And just like the phoenix that departed, Dumbledore had left Hogwarts forever. Left the mortal world. Left Harry."

I don't know why, but that line was sad to me for some reason.

i cried at the end of the the seventh because fred and alot of my other favorite carictors died. i got a soft heart-_-

[Gweagle]

Voldemort wasn't a horcrux. He was just his own thing.

[sporty chik 27]

Harry wasn't a hrocrux, Nagini was.

Actually both Harry and Nagini were Horcruxes. But Voldemort accidentally created the Horcrux inside Harry and didn't know about it. The piece of Voldemort's soul inside Harry was the reason he could see inside Voldemort's mind and speak Parseltongue.


If Harry was the seventh Horcrux, was Nagini a Horcrux? Cause Neville killed her, and if she was there would be 8 Horcruxes:
1. Riddle's Diary
2. Marvolo's Ring
3. Slytherin's Locket
4. Huflepuff's Cup
5. Ravenclaw's "Die-dum" (lol, Crabbe is stupid)
6. Nagini(Was she?)
7. Harry
8. Voldemort's Body



And did you cry at the death of any of the characters? I'm the kind of reader that gets too much involved in the story so when someone dies I feel like I lost someone, so I cried when Dumbledore, Fred and Dobby died, not Tonks nor Lupin, cause JK didn't narrate their deaths, and I was sad for Snape, after I read "The Prince's Tale", Fred's death was the saddest for me, cause he was a cool guy and always had good jokes.


Voldemort's body wasn't a Horcrux.
I did cry for some of the deaths. I cried for Dumbledore (HBP), Fred (DH), Sirius (OotP), and Dobby (DH). Probably because their deaths were described in such great detail.

[benas789]

Harry was horcux and he let Voldemort kill him but Voldemort only destroyed his own soul in Harrys body so harry surrvived :) and volemorts body wasn't one because horcuxes are parts of your soul put in different object which help you reincornate(i think)

[Bsaved]

When Voldemort tried to kill Harry was he was a baby, he accidentally made him into horcrux. And he didn't know he had made Harry into one. I think.

I cried when Hedwig died! I loved Hewig! Also when Dumbledore died, Lupin died, Sirius died, (Even though that was in a different book) and when Fred died. I think it was awesome that Ron and Hermione ended up getting married, and Harry and Ginny got married. I thought Harry and Hermione should have been together.

[Purple Pirate]

Harry was an accidental horcrux.

[Pen Rua]

Harry was an accidental horcrux.

I don't think he was... It makes sense, Harry being a horcrux because Voldermort gave Harry half his powers.

[Bsaved]

I don't think he was... It makes sense, Harry being a horcrux because Voldermort gave Harry half his powers.

"Yeah, Harry was an accidental horcrux. Voldemort meant to kill him, but b/c Lily Potter gave her life to save him he had that protection. But Voldemort didn't know. That is why when Voldemort tried to kill Harry, he became weaker, b/c he had just split is soul again.

(I think it is funny my spell checker says Voldemort isn't a real word)

[penguindude515]

Voldemort wasn't a "horcrux"... He was the original body of the soul, and the horcrux is only when you put your soul into something/someone else other than your own body.

Fred ruled, but George was cooler. He has no ear.:cool:

Harry wasn't a hrocrux, Nagini was.

They were both horcruxes. Read the chapter "King's Cross" and Dumbledore says to Harry "You were the seventh horcrux". Otherwise, why would Harry have had to let Voldemort kill him?

Voldemort wasn't a horcrux. He was just his own thing.

Did you even read the book?
If Harry was a Horcrux than he would have to die for voldermort to be dead.

Technically, he did die. Voldemort killed him, but Harry couldn't die unless Voldemort died so when Voldemort used the killing curse on Harry he killed the part of himself in Harry and the of Harry in himself. That's why Voldemort 'fainted' when he tried to kill Harry.

[Madfly]

They were both horcruxes. Read the chapter "King's Cross" and Dumbledore says to Harry "You were the seventh horcrux". Otherwise, why would Harry have had to let Voldemort kill him?


Harry had to let Voldemort kill him becuase he threatened to blow up the whole hogwarts.
(not completely sure, read it like a year ago.)

[penguindude515]

Harry had to let Voldemort kill him becuase he threatened to blow up the whole hogwarts.
(not completely sure, read it like a year ago.)

Lol, and because he was a horcrux. Maybe you should refresh your memory. ;)

[legoless]

If Harry was the seventh Horcrux, was Nagini a Horcrux? Cause Neville killed her, and if she was there would be 8 Horcruxes:
1. Riddle's Diary
2. Marvolo's Ring
3. Slytherin's Locket
4. Huflepuff's Cup
5. Ravenclaw's "Die-dum" (lol, Crabbe is stupid)
6. Nagini(Was she?)
7. Harry
8. Voldemort's Body



And did you cry at the death of any of the characters? I'm the kind of reader that gets too much involved in the story so when someone dies I feel like I lost someone, so I cried when Dumbledore, Fred and Dobby died, not Tonks nor Lupin, cause JK didn't narrate their deaths, and I was sad for Snape, after I read "The Prince's Tale", Fred's death was the saddest for me, cause he was a cool guy and always had good jokes.

Yeah, like other people have said, Voldemort wasn't a horcrux.

----

I got a lump in my throat when Dobby died, & I was annoyed when Dumbledore died. He wasn't meant to go till the last book. :(

[Mastersnowy]

Harry was a Horcrux created accidentaly when Voldemort tried to kill him. Voldemort just didn't know it.

I cried a bit when Lupin and Tonks died because I cried thinking about their newborn son. I was a bit happy when Snape died, but after reading the Prince's Tale, that changed everything. Also, this doesn't count as a death, but I cried a bit when SPOILERS!!! Harry and Dumbledore had the conversation at "Kings Cross" and Dumbledore told Harry everything about his sister and the Hallows.

[penguindude515]

Harry was a Horcrux created accidentaly when Voldemort tried to kill him. Voldemort just didn't know it.

I cried a bit when Lupin and Tonks died because I cried thinking about their newborn son. I was a bit happy when Snape died, but after reading the Prince's Tale, that changed everything. Also, this doesn't count as a death, but I cried a bit when SPOILERS!!! Harry and Dumbledore had the conversation at "Kings Cross" and Dumbledore told Harry everything about his sister and the Hallows.

If you want to keep people from knowing anything about the book, you might as well turn all of your post white, but people are smart to know to not come here if they don't want spoilers.

[GluGluCute]

Yes, Nagini was a horcrux.

It was really sad that Fred died. I mean, without Fred, there isn't any Fred and George!! UGH! Why did J.K. Rowling have to do that to us?!? I mean..it's like cutting out the bread from the butter!!!! Sorry if that doesn't make sense. -.-

[LiTE]

8 pieces of soul in total.

Fred was cooler than George. I'm so sad he died. Actually, she killed off all of my favorite characters, except Luna.

[benas789]

8 pieces of soul in total.

Fred was cooler than George. I'm so sad he died. Actually, she killed off all of my favorite characters, except Luna.

maybe J.K. just dosen't like you lol xD