Official Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Thread*Come Here to discuss the book

[conman1001]

Well I just finished it, 9 hours new record for me but let's talk about the book shall we?

Rate, discuss what you thought about the deaths. Why somethings caught you off guard.

Also, please mark Spoilers with
Spoiler! in your post.



Spoiler
I thought that Hagrid was dead but it turned out he wasn't. Go figure.:rolleyes:

I wonder which characters she intended not to kill but Rowling had to.
I think that Dobby was an unnecessary kill.

Discuss the book and what you thought here!

[JJDach]

um, no offense, but some peopple havn't even read the book like me. I'm not even interested in buying it.:rolleyes:

[kezzamanezza]

Well I just finished it, 9 hours new record for me but let's talk about the book shall we?

Rate, discuss what you thought about the deaths. Why somethings caught you off guard.

Also, please mark Spoilers with
Spoiler! in your post.



Spoiler
I thought that Hagrid was dead but it turned out he wasn't. Go figure.:rolleyes:

I wonder which characters she intended not to kill but Rowling had to.
I think that Dobby was an unnecessary kill.

Discuss the book and what you thought here!

why would hagrid be dead?

i just finished it now, it was great!

[Sixpenguin]

I finished it,. It's epic. Here is my official list of people who got killed off:

*SPOILER WARNING!*









~Hedwig
~Moody
~Dobby
~Lupin
~Tonks
~Fred
~Bellatrix (I think)
~Voldemort
~50 Unknown others who died in the battle of Hogwarts









END SPOILERS!



Well, it's now my favorite book of all time.

[Powdinet]

I finished it,. It's epic. Here is my official list of people who got killed off:

*SPOILER WARNING!*









~Hedwig
~Moody
~Dobby
~Lupin
~Tonks
~Fred
~Bellatrix (I think)
~Voldemort
~50 Unknown others who died in the battle of Hogwarts









END SPOILERS!



Well, it's now my favorite book of all time.

Anyway, I haven read it yet, I just know its going o be cool...

[Bad Boy]

SPOILERS BELOW
SPOILERS BELOW
SPOILERS BELOW










This book has the most named casualties of any book in the series. 54 died opposing Voldemort in the battle: "Fred, Tonks, Lupin, Colin Creevey, and fifty others".

List of characters killed:


Charity Burbage
Hedwig
Alastor Moody
Rufus Scrimgeour
Bathilda Bagshot
Ted Tonks
Dirk Cresswell
Gornuk
Gregorovitch
Gellert Grindelwald
Wormtail
Dobby
Remus Lupin
Nymphadora Tonks
Vincent Crabbe
Severus Snape
Fred Weasly
Colin Creevy
Nagini
Antonin Dolohov
Bellatrix Lestrange
Lord Voldemort


So many deaths... Many died in the battle of Hogwarts.

The movie must be fun! But oh, 3 years.

More information on their cause of death, or details. Click here. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_potter_and_the_deathly_hallows#List_of_chara cters_killed)

Source: Wikipedia

[Pieeip]

Definitely a 10/10. I am only about a quarter way though which is where...

SPOILER ALERT (In a way..)

Harry, Ron and Hermione are in Sirius Black's old house, that he left Harry in his will, and they just sent Kreacher to find the person who has the locket with one of the Horcruxses in it.

[Cain]

Thread has already been made.

http://penguinforum.miniclip.com/showthread.php?t=14149

[Snowball3028]

I'm confused because I decided to read the end and I noticed the words: "said sirius". Didn't he die in order of the phoenix?

[Rigsandbill]

I started an eighth book.

http://penguinforum.miniclip.com/showthread.php?t=22186

Read and comment.

[conman1001]

I started an eighth book.

http://penguinforum.miniclip.com/showthread.php?t=22186

Read and comment.

Rigs I didn't want to comment there because I might spoil the secret but
Oh and Cain I would be bumping it and that was before the book this is for people who have read it.
Spoiler
You forgot Ginny is married to Harry and Crabbe is dead.

[Rigsandbill]

Rigs I didn't want to comment there because I might spoil the secret but
Oh and Cain I would be bumping it and that was before the book this is for people who have read it.
Spoiler
You forgot Ginny is married to Harry and Crabbe is dead.

This takes place when Harry is eighteen, and the Crabbe in this story is Vincent Crabbe's cousin.

And you wouldn't be bumping by posting there, it isn't even on the second page yet.

[conman1001]

This takes place when Harry is eighteen, and the Crabbe in this story is Vincent Crabbe's cousin.

And you wouldn't be bumping by posting there, it isn't even on the second page yet.

Whoops, I didn't see it I just saw that the last post was in June.:|

Well I guess your right but apart from that good job.

Edit: Maybe I should put your progress in the first post saying the unofficial 8th book by Rigs.

[Rigsandbill]

Whoops, I didn't see it I just saw that the last post was in June.:|

Well I guess your right but apart from that good job.

Edit: Maybe I should put your progress in the first post saying the unofficial 8th book by Rigs.

Call it, "YEAR EIGHT: Harry Potter and the Shadow Avengers"

[conman1001]

Sure ok now it's time to copy and paste.
Spoiler
Oh and I thought Hagrid was dead because he fell into the swarm of spiders.

Edit: Sorry missed those errors.

[Rigsandbill]

Sure ok now it's time to copy and paste.
Spoiler
Oh and I thought Hagrid was dead because he fell into the swarm of spiders.

That's only page 1 of the book, don't say it's the offical eighth book, say it's the preview of the unofficial eighth book.

[Captain Kool]

Aww, Snape died he owns, "I am Snape the potions master.. heh heh"-_-

I haven't read it yet, since my Mom claims she's too busy to take me to the book store.-_-

[Black Dragon]

I'm confused because I decided to read the end and I noticed the words: "said sirius". Didn't he die in order of the phoenix?
Harry uses the reurection stone to bring sirius to come back a bit like a ghost.

[music and lyrics]

wow you actually read it?! that must have taken FOREVER lol i tryed reading goblet of fire but it was way too long

[Black Dragon]

wow you actually read it?! that must have taken FOREVER lol i tryed reading goblet of fire but it was way too long
Actualy, it only took me two days.:cool:

[conman1001]

Harry uses the reurection stone to bring sirius to come back a bit like a ghost.

Yes I know I was just flipping through to find how long it was and I saw "Said Lily."
I'm like oh my gosh.

[ArcboundMyr]

Harry Potter and the Shadow Avengers. By: Rigs
Harry Potter was sleeping in his home in Godric’s Hallow. Nobody was there, and all was quiet. Little did he know that miles away from this safe suburban home, a group of weary Death Eaters were creating a conspiracy.

Indeed, somewhere in a small village, three men were having a discussion inside a muddy, deserted hut. There names were Draco Malfoy, Samson Fennigs, and Crowley Crabbe. The room filled with a musty air as Malfoy paced down the hall, stroking a dark crimson snake.

“It’s been eighteen years, and I still have not served my purpose to the Lord. But how? How can I serve him? What is there to be done for a man of great accomplishment?”

Fennigs, a dark-skinned man of about twenty, spoke up.

“Draco, how many times must we explain? He is dead. Volde-”
“Don’t you dare speak his name, you despicable oaf! You were on Potter’s side.”

Malfoy said the word “Potter” with a hateful glare, as if this unfortunate boy was no more than a slobbering bull hound. In mid-step, Malfoy stopped and thought over what he had just said.

“Would it be considered a good deed for the fallen master if I killed Potter?”

At these words, Crabbe, who was usually quite silent, snorted. He had been a second-cousin of one of Malfoy’s old school friends, and he was proud to be so. His cousin had died fighting for Lord Voldemort, and this made him want to live up to Vincent Crabbe’s assistance to the Lord.

“You think my ideas are funny, do you Crowley? I reckon you are too cowardly to finish your cousin’s work.”

Crabbe instantly stopped. He had never known what his cousin had accomplished, and he was yearning to finally find out.
One problem: Crabbe died in the 7th book. OH! SPOILER!

[conman1001]

Rigs explained that to me that is Crabbe's cousin.

[Woofer Dog]

I miss Hedwig. It aint that great that Fred dies too.

[Brandon Inge]

um, no offense, but some peopple havn't even read the book like me. I'm not even interested in buying it.:rolleyes:

Don't post in the thread thens

[TnT]

SPOILERS BELOW











Grr, great book, but now there will be no more. :(
J.K. had to kill Dobby, Hedwig, and Fred didn't she. :(
Tonks and Lupin too!

Why didn't she kill Cho Chang or someone. :P

[Pieeip]

So far, I really like it. I can't put it down, and neither can my dad. I am at the part where Harry and Hermione are reading "The life and lies of Albus Dumbledore", which is around page 350.

[cwer]

I read a spolier site....thats all....:| lol..I only know whodies and get married.

[Rigsandbill]

SPOILERS BELOW











Grr, great book, but now there will be no more. :(
J.K. had to kill Dobby, Hedwig, and Fred didn't she. :(
Tonks and Lupin too!

Why didn't she kill Cho Chang or someone. :P

You suck Lestrange, you killed Dobby. :(

[Red Ribbon]

Yeah I read it.

!!Spoiler!! Drag Mouse over to read!
George's ear is cut of by Dark Magic!
Severus Snape is on Harry's side!
Harry is Horcrux Number 7
Hermione marries Ron and Harry marries Ginny.

~End of spoilers~

I would rate it an 8/10. The ending isn't the greatest that I would of hoped. I thought maybe that J.K. Rowling would not make it so much like a fairy tale, where the good always wins and the bad is defeated.

[TnT]

You suck Lestrange, you killed Dobby. :(

I agree, she also killed Sirius in book five, which sucked. :P

[wweadam]

I dont really care for harry potter books. When I was in fourth grade I liked them, i read the first 4 and Wished it was real, and then by fifth I didnt like them anymore.( im now in eighth grade so you can see how far ive grown apart from them.)
Ps. Whenever the movie comes out to this one ill probably watch it since there are that many deaths. Because I like to see Ron freak out. :D

[Ponchowinz]

Yes I know I was just flipping through to find how long it was and I saw "Said Lily."
I'm like oh my gosh.

That could be where Harry resurects her or it could be Harrys daughter, but anyway, that book pwns, I'm said I finished it, cause I wanted more, real great book. 10/10, and Snape rox.
I dont really care for harry potter books. When I was in fourth grade I liked them, i read the first 4 and Wished it was real, and then by fifth I didnt like them anymore.( im now in eighth grade so you can see how far ive grown apart from them.)
Ps. Whenever the movie comes out to this one ill probably watch it since there are that many deaths. Because I like to see Ron freak out. :D
You don't know what you're missing by not reading the 7th, it's like all the books' mysteries all put in one book, it's awesome.

[doodlesinclass]

I've never actually read any of the books. Ever since I was a kid, people said Harry Potter books we're too confusing (short intension spans).

But, I have watched all the movies! Does that seem right to you?

I decided to see for myself, I got my mom to buy me the latest and final Harry Potter book, "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows",

I've yet to read it yet because 1. I'm lazy, 2. I've been trying to finsih my extremely boring Summer Reading books first.

However, people say its good so I'm looking forward to reading it.

[waddles 4ever]

it was by far the best book in the series

[Andrewroid]

basically, everyone dies. only the main characters don't.

[Pr!nC3zZ]

I read the book.It was awesome.
Ugh Harry Potter is my guilty pleasure.:|
Harry marries Ginny.Ron marries Hermione.
Etc.etc.I can't believe I actually read the whole
thing.It's the longest book I have ever read since
I never read.Lol Snape liked Harry's mom.

[Tuxy]

that HEDWIG DIES:!: He was so cool. -_-

[DirkD]

The book was absolutely outstanding! I loved it. The storyline was well put and the way she worked around the horcruxes with the deathly hallows was amazing!

Dont you think that Lupin and Tonks were bound to die once Harry was told he was godfather. It was very well foreshadowed, since it happened to James and Lily Potter.

[cricket king]

Well I just finished it, 9 hours new record for me but let's talk about the book shall we?

Rate, discuss what you thought about the deaths. Why somethings caught you off guard.

Also, please mark Spoilers with
Spoiler! in your post.



Spoiler
I thought that Hagrid was dead but it turned out he wasn't. Go figure.:rolleyes:

I wonder which characters she intended not to kill but Rowling had to.
I think that Dobby was an unnecessary kill.

Discuss the book and what you thought here!I read the book like 2, 3 weeks ago and i found it wasn't that good. The ending i felt was rushed and i was longing for a evil end but it turned out to be a happy ending :(

[Potterania]

Spoilers
Nineteen years later, Harry is married to Ginny Weasley, and they have three children: James, Albus Severus, and Lily. Ron and Hermione are also married and have two children, Rose and Hugo. The families meet at King's Cross station, where a nervous Albus is departing for his first year at Hogwarts. James, the eldest, is already familiar with school while Lily will start in two years' time. Harry's nineteen-year-old godson, Teddy Lupin, is found kissing Victoire Weasley (Bill and Fleur's daughter) in a train compartment. Teddy is apparently very close to the Potters, with Harry remarking, "He already comes round for dinner about four times a week." Harry spots Draco Malfoy and his unnamed wife with their son, Scorpius; Malfoy acknowledges Harry with a curt nod, then turns away. Harry comforts Albus, who is worried he will be sorted into Slytherin, by telling him that his namesake, Severus Snape, was a Slytherin and the bravest man he ever met. He adds that the sorting hat takes one's own choice into account. Neville Longbottom is now the Hogwarts Herbology professor and is close friends with Harry. The book concludes with the words: "The scar had not pained Harry for nineteen years. All was well."

:|:)

[Author]

This book is my favorite ever. But you'd think she would of let one of the main characters die. (Harry/Ron/Hermione)

[Lilly 309]

i gave it an 8/10 because it was very confuzzling

[mickey4741]

10/10. I really loved it. The epilogue was cool too. :D I cant wait to see the movie! :)
Author harry did die... but then he came back to life. So technically, he did. :p

[Andrewroid]

i think it deserved only a 6/10, rowling didn't make any one of the main characters die (which should've happened.) and jumps too quickly through the book.

[penguindude515]

i think it deserved only a 6/10, rowling didn't make any one of the main characters die (which should've happened.) and jumps too quickly through the book.

I agree with the main character dieing thing, but she didn't jump through quickly through the book, only some parts. If she streached out every part of the book, it would've gotten boring.

[FireBlaze]

I only saw the movie I havent read the book yet.

[Tortoli]

Well I just finished it, 9 hours new record for me but let's talk about the book shall we?

Rate, discuss what you thought about the deaths. Why somethings caught you off guard.

Also, please mark Spoilers with
Spoiler! in your post.



Spoiler
I thought that Hagrid was dead but it turned out he wasn't. Go figure.:rolleyes:

I wonder which characters she intended not to kill but Rowling had to.
I think that Dobby was an unnecessary kill.

Discuss the book and what you thought here!


I think it was a great and noble death for Dobby. I would have prefered for Kreacher to die though. It would be just as tragic, because Kreacher was starting to be nice to Harry. Here's a question to think about; did Harry really die and come back to like if he didn't die then what did happen? I think this is a subject we could seriously deabate about forever, because there really is no asnwer, it is up to your imagination. Sometimes thinks are great because they are left unanswered. The book was great! Action packed all the way through! I give it a 10/10. It was a fitting end to the Harry Potter series.

[penguindude515]

I only saw the movie I havent read the book yet.

The movie isn't out yet. This is Deathly Hollows discussion.