Pro Sig Competition Voting!

[kogeck]

Well, it's abeen a great week, and all of the artists did an excellant job.
Please vote who you think's the best one.

Kogeck:
http://i16.tinypic.com/52ghcn9.jpg

Little Milky:
http://i111.photobucket.com/albums/n127/LittleMilky_01/bradcompsig.png

Icy Chris:
http://i166.photobucket.com/albums/u86/Icy_chris/finalyfantsay.png

Penguindude515:
http://i7.tinypic.com/6b4qzrm.gif

[evanrox23™]

You forgot to add a poll Kogeck. I always forget to add a poll.:rolleyes:

EDIT:You added a poll nvm.

[Redenator]

ICy got my vote. Kogeck's was too Bright, I didn't like Milky's text, and PenguinDude the background looks scratched.

[!Icy Chris!]

The poll is up, Good luck everyone.

[Dark]

Little Milky = 9.7/10. (Sorry LM)
Icy Crhis = 10/10.

[Kanilho]

I'll give my thoughts and rate each piece of artwork before making up my mid about who will I vote for.

-----------------------------------------------------

Kogeck's: Too light overall, the bkg is so bright that the lightning is all wrong, coming from everywhere. The paths are also appearing in the middle of the sig, without any need for them. Also, the border is too thick, which doesn't go with the overall flow of the sig.

5/10

-------------------------

LM's: A good-looking sig, with good lightning (soft and effective), the bkg is very good, going very well with the render colors and taking away the need of messing with the render itself. The left side of the bkg is a bit bland, which would go well with the text if it was placed diagonally IMO.
Personally, it is a really good sig.

9/10

-------------------------

Icy's: Another good-looking sig, in contrast with LM's, the bkg goes with the flow of the main color of the render (only) and has a nice rusty look, which really goes with the render. The text is merged with the bkg and its location is good since the sig has a lower width. The border is not very good, since the lack of an edge gives the feel that there is something missing, honestly a 1px black border in the edge would make it look a lot better. The overall color and brightness of the sig makes it eye-catching, though the lightning is a bit messed up.

9/10

-------------------------

Penguindude's: The bkg is messy and its color is completely wrong. The render is not bad and its blending attempt works.
There's not really much to say about this one since the bkg color ruins it, still, if there had been more work in the bkg, it could be a really good sig.

7/10


---------------------------------------------------------------------

I'm not sure wheter to vote for Lm's or Icy's... both are very good sigs made by excellent artists, but, I think I'll have to vote for Lm's.
Even if it's not as eye-catching as Icy's it has a nice contrast between the bkg and the render and fits better in my idea of "what I would do with this render".

Little Milky gets my vote.

[Makarov]

Oh well,I am the only vote for Kogeck. You should of posted the theme.

[!Icy Chris!]

I voted for LM. I like the b/g, even though the colors dont match.

[Black Hawk]

Brad's is just flat out hawt. Icy Chris's is too bright.

[Stick Slaughter]

Little milky gets my vote. I love the darkness, the other ones are too lightly colored for my taste.