TRading with other penguins

[Spray]

Wouldnt that be cool if you could trade cloths and coins with other penguins? Or just give some cloths or furniture you dont want to other people or even non-members! I think that would be great for everyone:)

[!~Hi/2 o o 6~!]

This has been talked about a lot, and I personally wouldn't care. Everyone would just try to pay a lot for rare items, and Club Penguin would turn into a "Popular for clothes", ect. game.

[Spray]

I guess so, its just that i have some friends at school that arent members and i would want to give them some cloths

[Greenboy26]

yeah that would be kool but it should only be for members not non-members

[.::deetz::.]

I dont think so.First hackers are millioners so they would give like 12000000 for a party hat and still the could recover that money.So its just a loss.I thought of that when i was a noob and didnt think of other people but know i know;)

[Madfly]

I wish we could atleast return stuff we don't want.... Then it could be in a catalog of stuff returned....

[Burninator]

i saw this idea like 5 times already in this new forum and i kinda like it

[11dx11]

Yes someone already posted a thread on this Idea but No, I don't like It.....
The only reason I say that Is because If theres one Item that One person wants from another and the other person does'nt want to give It to them the other might bother the person till they go crazy

[Babidu]

It is a good idea, but it wouldn't be so easy to do.

It would be really for hackers to hack other people clothes, so I don't really support the idea.

[xogymnastx]

yeah, i asked about this before and the club penguin team member said the bad thing is that hackers could just trade all your stuff so yeah.

[Yellowtail]

I don't want trading... CP can't turn into RUNESCAPE! :sick:

[Darth John]

i like the idea of getting rid of items but not like trading

[AkaBob22]

If this ever happend, this game might as well be called "Runepenguin".

[Patman58]

Well, I have seen this idea many times. For a while I thought it was cool. I still do, but hackers would take advantage of it.


Nice idea but many people have posted this.


- Patman

[Guardian Ou]

You know, most of the ideas people are suggesting are really kinda like RuneScape's system. Club Penguin may become a bit like RuneScape system-wise.

[New Guy]

I think the idea is great but then you have to think of the problems.
If you are a penguin with all the items.
Could you imagen how many people would bother you to get them.
Already many memebrs are complaining that the newer penguins are annoying, Think of it then,

And then think of Non-members and members,
How would they trade clothing, A member woulden`t give there clothing to a non-member that doesen`t pay.

It might happen but no were from now.:(

New Guy

[Spray]

Thanx guys for you opinions. I doubt mods would ever allow trading, so Club Penguin should be good for now.

[nickster532]

I think that would be cool because I have some items I really wanna get rid of

[greenday6199]

Wouldnt that be cool if you could trade cloths and coins with other penguins? Or just give some cloths or furniture you dont want to other people or even non-members! I think that would be great for everyone:)

well its really a good idea and I would love it but than non members wouldnt become members cause they can get member stuff that way. so cp would need to make member and non member servers

[Db Penguin]

Finnaly Someone Who Got The Idea That I Have Yea We Ashould Be Able To Trade Stuff!:d

[Snowball3028]

I guess so, its just that i have some friends at school that arent members and i would want to give them some cloths

Then what would be the point of membership? Then you could only decorate igloos.

[Bridget]

I hope this doesent happen then people will go like "Donate clothes please!" And that would be annoying.

[Zacheroo]

This has been talked about a lot, and I personally wouldn't care. Everyone would just try to pay a lot for rare items, and Club Penguin would turn into a "Popular for clothes", ect. game.

Thats Already Happened.

You're Right. This Would Just Be Feeding The "Fame-Game" Theary.

~-:.Zacheroo.:-~

[razzelfrazel]

no, that would make cp just like runescape which causes flame wars, you should see the banks iin rs there are people yelling and screaming by this!

[I Estella I]

I'm going to take both sides on this. I mean, it could be good if you wanted to help out a friend, and give them a shirt or something like that. But, non-members would bug other penguins for their rare items and it would be chaos. I think that there should be like a card o something that delivers a gift, but it can only be sent to your buddies. This way, people wouldn't gp crazy and drive you insane over your items.

[skate punk 1]

This has been talked about a lot, and I personally wouldn't care. Everyone would just try to pay a lot for rare items, and Club Penguin would turn into a "Popular for clothes", ect. game.

as if its not already? sadly......

I hope this doesent happen then people will go like "Donate clothes please!" And that would be annoying.

yea i was thinking the same thing. every 1 second: press 555 to buy rare item!!!!or givving away 1000000 coins!!!!!!

I'm going to take both sides on this. I mean, it could be good if you wanted to help out a friend, and give them a shirt or something like that. But, non-members would bug other penguins for their rare items and it would be chaos. I think that there should be like a card o something that delivers a gift, but it can only be sent to your buddies. This way, people wouldn't gp crazy and drive you insane over your items.

yea but then we will get 1,000,000 buddy requests just so they can trade with us



this would be a good idea if:
1. no one would say press 555 to buy stuff(ect.)
2. there would be a third request thing that you type to the person: do you wanna trade____ for ______?
3. you cant get items that came out before you joined. if you missed an item or weren't a member that is your chance to get the item.
4. you have the option the ask a player to see their inventory list so you can see what the have(notice i said ask)
5. you can block people who anoy you endlessly to buy/sell/trade an item
:D

[dethangl2]

:mod: That would be pretty cool........:mod:

[penguinp]

That would be awsome. Who knows maybe in the future they will make that. :P

[!Icy Chris!]

Dont you people understand? Come on, yes we know , we know..hackers right? Well why would they take advantage of it if they already can get whatever they want? They can get the party hat or flower hat whatever by hacking with the ID #. So forget about the hackers, think about the 7 years olds that would chase you areound saying him gonna report j001!!

^^ Think about that for a sec.

I doubt we will get banned for that though.The mods can see with thier own eyes why we got reported so the overal message is i think its a good idea!:D

[blueberry258]

Wasn't this already talked about??? Anyways, good thinking..

[Hammy120]

I thought of that one time, but now I realize, then whiney non-members would constantly follow members and bug them going, "CAN YOU GIVE ME THAT ITEM!!!!! I WAAAAAAAAAANNTTT IT, AND I CAN'T PAY A SIMPLE 6 DOLLARS FOR YOUR STUFF!! GIVE IT!!!!-_- "

[Jug Jug]

i would thiink a good idea is:if they ask polite like:can you please donate a few items

[soul lord111]

i agree , although this game would turn into a runescape sort of game...

If this didnt happen, id atleast suggest being to give back items to catalouges for the same price you bought them for, i mean ive got like 1000,00000 coins worth of junk i dont even use in my furniture and clothing.

But because some players are younger, there would be the problem of begging.