Who read Eragon or Eldest?

[Chainzz]

I read both of them. If you didn't knnow, eldest is the second part of eragon. When i saw the picture, i thinked that the dragon was eragon:O .

[NIRVANAGIRL]

I've read and enjoyed both. The movie Eragon wasn't near as good as the book though.

[walmartshrty]

I've read and enjoyed both. The movie Eragon wasn't near as good as the book though.

I know! I definitely think that they really messed up the movie. Because the movie was so descriptive and the movie was just too short to bring out the true "essence" of the book. Ugh. Darn' movie makers always gotta be messing up my favorite books. :mad:

Yeah, I've read them both..I thought Eldest became boring in some places but besides that I'd say it was a good book. Eldest was kinda freaky though you know with the whole turning into the elf thing it was just kinda interesting/weird. Sorry if you didn't know about the elf thing.

Eragon 9.5/10
Eldest 7.9/10

[BubblyPengy]

i read both they are very good.

but the movie of eragon had 2 much witchcraft in it.

[Generalflopy Pwns]

Read Eragon and reading Eldest. Its really good so far.

[woofbark]

I've read both, and they are both super-awesome. The movie is good, but the book runs circles around it.

[conman1001]

I've read them both and know what will be on the cover for the third.

[Sweeper]

Wow I heard that that is the geekest book ever....

[walmartshrty]

Wow I heard that that is the geekest book ever....

*Slaps you cross the face* You got what you deserved though..Teehee..Game over for you. :P
It's good being the geekiest person on this forum. Because at least I know how to spell it. Psh.:P

[KingKitty]

*Slaps you cross the face* You got what you deserved though..Teehee..Game over for you. :P
It's good being the geekiest person on this forum. Because at least I know how to spell it. Psh.:P
Thank You RFS for banning him, he was rude to Nicole, and many others(including myself). On topic: I read it, and it's not my favorite book, but it's pretty good.

[Chainzz]

The movie was not even familiar to the book.


P.S. i like the forum admins, theyre cool :rolleyes:

[Flubs23]

I have read both and can't wait for the 3rd!

I agree, they completely messed of the movie! :mad:

[Riley Snow]

Read both, surprisingly. I hate reading books. Only books I ever read on my own time are those 2 and Harry Potter. And those 2 were Language Arts assignments.

[walmartshrty]

Thank You RFS for banning him, he was rude to Nicole, and many others(including myself). On topic: I read it, and it's not my favorite book, but it's pretty good.

It's not my favorite book either but I think it deserves a level of respect......I mean the guy who
wrote the thing was like 16 when he wrote it. And honestly he is a geek! So obviously it would be
sorta geeky! Geeky is good, right? :|

[KingKitty]

It's not my favorite book either but I think it deserves a level of respect......I mean the guy who
wrote the thing was like 16 when he wrote it. And honestly he is a geek! So obviously it would be
sorta geeky! Geeky is good, right? :|
Geeky is good as long as you don't go overboard on the geekiness, and collect complete sets of Star Wars action figures.

[walmartshrty]

Geeky is good as long as you don't go overboard on the geekiness, and collect complete sets of Star Wars action figures.

Hey, wait I love those Star Wars action figures. Lol. JK!

[Zeldafan114]

I'm working on my own video game version of the books, what does that kinda shout you ya?

[nr23nr]

ive read eregon it wasnt that good of a book.:cool: :cool: :cool:

[EPS55]

:O, Eragon Is my favorite book EVER! Im currently reading Eldest at the mo.

[Guite]

They were both such awsome books. Especially Eldest because of the fight scenes.
And they announced the 3rd book so long ago but it is still not out.:|

[Topoftheline]

I've been wanting to read those books but when I try to get them at the library they're all checked out.

[Nolaur]

Well... I liked the first one Eregon but the second one Eldest was SO boring so I quit half-way into the book:|

[blingstr]

i have read eragon and it was pretty good.
I have eldest but i havent gotten round to reading it yet :)

[Phrax]

Some of the best books I ever read. Cant wait for the third. I heard its coming out in the summer of 08!